ClaimBlood doctrineverified2000sOutcome

Blood doctrine · Claim record

Emma Gough, 22, died at the Royal Shrewsbury Hospital on 25 October 2007 after refusing blood following the birth of twins; the inquest pathologist said that with a transfusion 'the probability is very strongly in favour of the fact she would have survived'.

Claim ID claim-blood-case-goughConcerns 25 October 2007Outcome

The claim and its evidence

Outcome · 25 October 2007 Verified

Emma Gough, 22, died at the Royal Shrewsbury Hospital on 25 October 2007 after refusing blood following the birth of twins; the inquest pathologist said that with a transfusion 'the probability is very strongly in favour of the fact she would have survived'. Source: Shropshire Star, 5 November 2007Source: Shropshire Star, 7 April 2008Source: Shropshire Star, 8 April 2008Source: The Daily Telegraph (copy on culteducation.com), 6 November 2007

Show the evidence (4 sources)
Reputable reporting Verified

Shropshire Star, “Mum dies over blood refusal”

5 November 2007 · Shropshire Star

“the cause of death was recorded initially as complications of profound anaemia, due to haemorrhage and complications of a twin delivery. She died on October 25. An inquest was opened on October 30”

Emma Gough gave birth to healthy twins at the Royal Shrewsbury Hospital.

Provenance and verification note for Shropshire Star, Mum dies over blood refusal

Confidence note. Site 403 for WebFetch; retrieved with curl; headline and date (2007-11-05) confirmed from page metadata.

Corroborated by. src-telegraph-2007-1106-gough

Accessed. 19 September 2026 · Source ID. src-star-2007-1105-gough

Reputable reporting Verified

Shropshire Star, “Tragic mother refused blood”

7 April 2008 · Shropshire Star

“It is my view if she had received a transfusion the probability is very strongly in favour of the fact she would have survived.”

Consultant pathologist Dr Archibald Malcolm to coroner John Ellery; post-mortem haemoglobin 2.2 g/dL against about 14 in a healthy woman; Mrs Gough, 22, of Dawley, Telford, had signed an 'advance directive' refusing blood; died 25 Oct 2007 at the Royal Shrewsbury Hospital. The newspaper printed the haemoglobin figure as '2.2 milligrammes in 100 millilitres'; the site reports it as 2.2 (g/dL) without endorsing the unit as printed.

Provenance and verification note for Shropshire Star, Tragic mother refused blood

Confidence note. Retrieved with curl; date 2008-04-07 confirmed from metadata.

Corroborated by. src-star-2008-0408-gough-inquest

Accessed. 19 September 2026 · Source ID. src-star-2008-0407-gough-inquest

Reputable reporting Verified

Shropshire Star, “Mother who died 'was true to faith'”

8 April 2008 · Lisa Rowley · Shropshire Star

“But she had signed an advance directive saying she did not want a transfusion, a wish which was confirmed by her family when she was unconscious.”

Consultant gynaecologist Mr Oyesanya: had she received blood 'we would not be here today'; the family told him 'at least she remained faithful to her God'. The coroner's narrative verdict (reported elsewhere) was not opened.

Provenance and verification note for Shropshire Star, Mother who died 'was true to faith'

Confidence note. Retrieved with curl; date confirmed.

Corroborated by. src-star-2008-0407-gough-inquest

Notes. Living-person care: husband and children.

Accessed. 19 September 2026 · Source ID. src-star-2008-0408-gough-inquest

Reputable reporting Supported

The Daily Telegraph (copy on culteducation.com), “Mother dies after refusing blood transfusion”

6 November 2007 · Felix Lowe · Telegraph Media Group

“A 22-year-old woman who gave birth to healthy twins died hours later after reportedly refusing to receive a blood transfusion”

Reports staff asking her husband Anthony to consent; the hospital declined comment.

Provenance and verification note for The Daily Telegraph (copy on culteducation.com), Mother dies after refusing blood transfusion

Confidence note. Telegraph domain blocked; mirror opened. Facts match the Shropshire Star reports.

Scan provenance. Mirror on culteducation.com (Cult Education Institute)

Corroborated by. src-star-2007-1105-gough

Accessed. 19 September 2026 · Source ID. src-telegraph-2007-1106-gough

Claim page

A direct link to this claim is https://jwtruth.org/evidence/claim-blood-case-gough/. Every source above opens the original document or the best available copy. If you believe the wording, date or context is wrong, report an error.