California Court of Appeal, First District, Division Three, “Conti v. Watchtower Bible & Tract Society of New York, Inc., 235 Cal.App.4th 1214 (No. A136641)”
“The elders of the Fremont Congregation had no duty to depart from Watchtower's policy of confidentiality and warn the members of the Congregation that Kendrick had molested a child.”
The court reversed the punitive award but held that 'Defendants had a duty to use reasonable care to restrict and supervise Kendrick's field service to prevent him from harming children'. The 2012 Alameda County jury had awarded $7,000,000 compensatory and $21,000,001 punitive damages (about $28m); the trial court reduced the punitive award to $8,610,000. On appeal the compensatory verdict (reported as about $2.8m against the defendants after apportionment) was affirmed and the punitive award reversed with directions to enter judgment for Watchtower on that claim. The opinion describes a 1 July 1989 letter to elders on confidentiality and a 1 August 1995 letter saying 'steps should be taken to protect the child, or other children'.
Official source (opens in new tab) Archived or alternative copy (opens in new tab)
Provenance and verification note for California Court of Appeal, First District, Division Three, Conti v. Watchtower Bible & Tract Society of New York, Inc., 235 Cal.App.4th 1214 (No. A136641)
Confidence note. Full opinion opened on FindLaw; holdings and figures confirmed. Justia and Leagle copies were blocked or truncated.
Notes. Candace Conti waived anonymity and is the named plaintiff. The abuser (Kendrick) was a congregation member, not an elder.
Accessed. 19 September 2026 · Source ID. src-cal-2015-0413-conti-v-watchtower