ClaimRace, women and healthsupported1940sExplicit statement

Raza, mujeres y salud · Claim record

La Atalaya del 15 de septiembre de 1941 reseñó un discurso de asamblea de J. F. Rutherford en el que, al aconsejar en contra del matrimonio antes del fin esperado, preguntó: 'Why, then, should a man who has the prospect before him of being of the great multitude now tie himself up to a stack of bones and a hank of hair?' La reseña señala que la frase fue seguida de aplausos.

Claim ID claim-attitudes-1941-bones-and-hank-of-hairConcerns 15 de septiembre de 1941Declaración explícita

La afirmación y sus pruebas

Declaración explícita · 15 de septiembre de 1941 Respaldado

La Atalaya del 15 de septiembre de 1941 reseñó un discurso de asamblea de J. F. Rutherford en el que, al aconsejar en contra del matrimonio antes del fin esperado, preguntó: 'Why, then, should a man who has the prospect before him of being of the great multitude now tie himself up to a stack of bones and a hank of hair?' La reseña señala que la frase fue seguida de aplausos. Source: The Watchtower, 15 de septiembre de 1941Source: jwfacts.com, julio de 2022 (unverified)

La posición de la organización o su explicación posterior: Las publicaciones actuales de la organización dicen a los esposos que honren a sus esposas y afirman que Dios 'did not make men more intelligent or more talented than women'. Ninguna fuente de este archivo establece cuándo ni cómo se retiró el consejo de no casarse antes del fin; eso debería rastrearse y citarse antes de que el sitio diga nada al respecto.

Mostrar las pruebas (2 fuentes)
Publicación primaria de los testigos de Jehová Respaldado

The Watchtower

15 de septiembre de 1941 · p.287 · Watch Tower Bible and Tract Society

“Why, then, should a man who has the prospect before him of being of the great multitude now tie himself up to a stack of bones and a hank of hair?”

The page is part of an unsigned report of a convention discourse delivered by the organisation's president, J. F. Rutherford, and introduced on the same page by the chairman as 'CHILDREN OF THE KING'; '(Applause)' is marked through the report at intervals. The sentence quoted comes in a passage advising against marriage before the expected end, and the report prints it inside quotation marks, so it is given as Rutherford's own spoken words and not as the reporter's summary. The sentences on either side of it are the reporter's summary, unquoted.

Nota de procedencia y verificación for The Watchtower

Nota de confianza. The page image was downloaded and read on 19 September 2026, and the quoted sentence, the date and the page number were all legible on it. It is recorded as supported rather than verified because the only copy located is hosted by a site critical of the organisation: the Watchtower Online Library holds The Watchtower only from 1950, and no 1941 volume of the magazine is on the Internet Archive. The Internet Archive items titled 'The Watchtower 1940-1941' and 'The Watchtower 1941-1942' are the student newspaper of Wesleyan College, Macon, Georgia, and the item titled 'RIHS Watchtower 1941' is the yearbook of Rock Island Public High School, Rock Island, Illinois; none of the three is Watch Tower Society material. The Internet Archive does hold a French-language Watch Tower volume for 1941 (item '2b-1941', 'La Tour de Garde - Année 1941'), which would have served as an independent witness; its issue for 15 September 1941 was opened and does not carry this convention report, that edition being an abridged translation. No second copy of the page exists that this audit could reach.

Procedencia del escaneo. Photographic scan of the printed page hosted by jwfacts.com (discovery site); no copy held by the organisation or by a library was located. The image is a photograph of a magazine page carrying the running head 'September 15, 1941 The WATCHTOWER 287', in the two-column setting and typeface of the magazine of that period, and it was read as an image in this session. Its chain of custody is a single critical site and it cannot be checked against another copy.

Notes. The phrase echoes Rudyard Kipling's 1897 poem 'The Vampire' ('A rag and a bone and a hank of hair'). Secondary sites say Rutherford used the expression in public talks generally; what the scan establishes is its appearance in this convention report. The same page reports him saying of a resurrected Deborah: 'Soon you will see Barak and Deborah (I got a picture of her in this book), and when you see her you will love her very much. She is a real woman . . .' (the sentence runs on past the foot of the page).

Consultado. 19 de septiembre de 2026 · Identificador de la fuente. src-wom-w-1941-0915-convention-report

Solo fuente de localización Sin verificar

jwfacts.com, “Watchtower's View of Women / Watchtower Quotes Regarding Women's role, submission and headship”

julio de 2022 · Paul Grundy · jwfacts.com

A site critical of the organisation which collects citations on this subject. It was used here only to find out which publications, issues and pages to look at; every quotation recorded in this file was then read in the publication itself, except where the entry says otherwise.

Nota de procedencia y verificación for jwfacts.com, Watchtower's View of Women / Watchtower Quotes Regarding Women's role, submission and headship

Nota de confianza. Read on 19 September 2026 as a finding aid. Nothing on this page is treated as evidence. Where its citations were checked against the originals, most page references were accurate; the exceptions are recorded in the notes of the individual sources.

Notes. The page states the date of its last update as July 2022.

Consultado. 19 de septiembre de 2026 · Identificador de la fuente. src-wom-jwfacts-womens-place

Página de la afirmación Corregir o actualizar

A direct link to this claim is https://jwtruth.org/es/evidence/claim-attitudes-1941-bones-and-hank-of-hair/. Every source above opens the original document or the best available copy. If you believe the wording, date or context is wrong, report an error.